If you're investing time and money into content, you want to know if it’s actually paying off. This guide is for marketers, content managers, and anyone sick of “gut feeling” reports. We'll go step-by-step through tracking and measuring your content ROI using MarketMuse analytics features. No fluff, just practical steps, honest pros and cons, and a fair look at what’s worth your time.
Step 1: Define What ROI Means for Your Content
Before you start pulling analytics, get clear about your version of ROI. Content ROI isn’t just “did we get more traffic?” It could be:
- Leads or signups
- Revenue (if you can track it)
- Organic keyword growth
- Cost savings over paid ads
- Authority or topical coverage
Pro tip: Pick 1-2 core goals per campaign, not 10. If you measure everything, you’ll understand nothing.
What to skip: Don’t just default to pageviews or “engagement.” They’re easy to measure but not always tied to business results.
Step 2: Set Up Your Content Inventory in MarketMuse
MarketMuse works best when it has a full view of your content. Start by:
- Importing your content URLs or connecting your site
- Making sure your main pages and blog posts are included
- Tagging or grouping content by topic, funnel stage, or campaign (if you want to compare performance later)
Reality check: MarketMuse’s auto-import isn’t always perfect. Double-check that your key content is in there, especially landing pages or older posts.
Step 3: Use the Inventory Dashboard for Baseline Metrics
With your content loaded, head to the Inventory Dashboard. Here’s what actually matters:
- Page Authority & Topical Authority: Shows which pages are trusted by Google and how deep your coverage is on your main topics.
- Traffic Estimates: MarketMuse pulls this from integrations or its own models. It’s not perfect, but it gives you directional data.
- Content Score: Tells you how well a page covers the topic compared to competitors.
What works: Use these as your “before” picture. You need this baseline to measure improvement.
What to ignore: Vanity metrics like “inventory size” or MarketMuse’s own “potential” numbers if you can’t tie them to real goals. They’re fun, but not actionable for ROI.
Step 4: Set Up and Track Content Changes
Whenever you publish or update content, log it. In MarketMuse, you can:
- Mark content as updated or new
- Add notes about what changed (e.g., “added FAQ section” or “targeting new keyword”)
- Set reminders to check back in 30/60/90 days
Pro tip: This makes it way easier to compare “before and after,” which is what actually shows ROI.
What to skip: Don’t obsess over every tweak. Track only major updates, new content, or strategic changes.
Step 5: Analyze Performance with MarketMuse Analytics
After a few weeks or months, start measuring. Here’s what to look at:
a) Topic Performance
- See how your content is ranking for target keywords
- Check if you’re appearing for more related terms (MarketMuse calls this “topical breadth”)
- Look for increases in “Top 10” or “Top 20” rankings
Reality check: Don’t expect overnight jumps. Good content improvements take time—think months, not days.
b) Content Score Improvement
- Compare old vs. new Content Scores
- See if higher scores actually lead to more traffic or better rankings (sometimes they do, sometimes they don’t)
What works: Content Score is a decent leading indicator, but it’s not magic. Use it as a sign you’re on the right track, not as final proof of ROI.
c) Competitive Gap Analysis
- Use the “Compete” or “Research” features to see if you’re catching up or passing competitors on key topics
- Identify content gaps that, if filled, could get you more traffic or authority
What to ignore: Don’t chase every single gap. Focus on gaps tied to ROI goals—like topics that drive conversions or revenue.
Step 6: Connect Google Analytics & Search Console (Optional but Helpful)
The truth: MarketMuse’s built-in traffic estimates are just that—estimates. For real ROI tracking, connect your Google Analytics and Google Search Console accounts if possible. This lets you:
- Pull in actual traffic, conversion, and engagement data
- Tie content updates to real-world results (leads, signups, sales)
- Build reports that matter to your boss or client
Heads up: The integration process isn’t always plug-and-play. You might need to map content manually or sort out permissions.
What to skip: If your organization is strict on data privacy or you just want to keep things simple, you can stick with MarketMuse’s estimates. Just know they’re not gospel.
Step 7: Calculate Content ROI (The Honest Way)
Now for the part everyone cares about: did your content make you money (or save you some)? Here’s a no-nonsense approach:
- Tally Up Your Content Costs
- Writer fees, editing, design, and your own time
-
Any spend on MarketMuse or other tools
-
Estimate Value Generated
- New leads, conversions, or sales tracked back to the content (from GA, GSC, or your CRM)
-
If you can’t track revenue, estimate what you’d pay for that traffic via ads (e.g., value of organic clicks)
-
Do the Math
- ROI = (Value Generated - Cost) / Cost x 100%
Caveat: Attribution is messy. Not every sale has a clear “last click” from a blog post. Don’t sweat perfection—directional insight is better than nothing.
What to ignore: Don’t bother with “soft ROI” like “brand lift” unless you have a way to measure it. Otherwise, it’s just guesswork.
Step 8: Report What Matters (and Skip the Fluff)
When you’re ready to share results with your team or boss, focus on:
- What changed (e.g., updated 10 product pages, added 3 new guides)
- What happened (traffic up 30%, new leads up 20%, rankings improved)
- What you’ll do next (double down on what worked, skip what didn’t)
Pro tip: Screenshots from MarketMuse dashboards are handy, but don’t let the visuals do all the talking. Explain the “so what?” in plain English.
What to skip: Endless slides full of bar charts and buzzwords. People just want to know: did it work, what did we learn, and what’s next?
What MarketMuse Analytics Does Well (and Where It Falls Short)
What Works
- Spotting content gaps and quick wins: If you want to find where you’re behind competitors, MarketMuse is solid.
- Benchmarking your content: The Content Score and topical authority features are useful for seeing how you stack up.
- Guiding new content: The platform can point you to topics worth covering, based on what drives ROI elsewhere.
What Doesn’t
- Traffic and conversion accuracy: The built-in numbers are best guesses, not gospel. Always back up with your own analytics.
- Measuring “brand” or “influence”: Not possible—stick to what you can count.
- Automated ROI calculations: MarketMuse won’t spit out a magic ROI number. You still have to do the thinking.
Keep It Simple, Iterate Often
Tracking content ROI isn’t rocket science, but it does require discipline. Start with clear goals, use MarketMuse for what it’s good at, and don’t drown in dashboards. Check your numbers regularly, learn what’s moving the needle, and tweak your approach as you go.
Don’t let “perfect” get in the way of “done.” Set up your system, stick with it, and remember: the best ROI is the one you actually measure (and act on).