If you're sending campaigns and hoping for the best, you're probably wasting your time—and your email list’s patience. This guide is for anyone who uses Mailreef, or is considering it, and wants real answers about what’s working (and what’s not) with their email campaigns. Forget vanity metrics and dashboard clutter. Let’s get into the nuts and bolts of tracking, analyzing, and actually learning from your Mailreef campaigns.
1. Get Your Tracking Basics Right
Before you even think about analyzing numbers, make sure Mailreef is set up to capture the right data. Out of the box, Mailreef tracks the essentials: opens, clicks, bounces, unsubscribes, and some engagement stats. But don’t just assume it’s all working.
Checklist to start: - Authenticate your domain. If you haven’t set up DKIM and SPF, your emails might end up in spam, which ruins your stats from the get-go. - Check your audience segments. Garbage in, garbage out. If your lists are outdated or not properly segmented, your numbers won’t mean much. - Enable link tracking. This should be on by default, but double-check. No click tracking = no real insight.
Pro tip: Test with a small segment before a big send. Make sure opens and clicks are being logged the way you expect.
2. Understand What Metrics Actually Matter
Mailreef throws a lot of numbers at you. Don’t get distracted by the flashy charts. Here’s what you should actually pay attention to, and what you can probably ignore:
Metrics Worth Your Time:
- Open Rate: Decent for a quick gut-check, but Apple Mail privacy changes mean this is less reliable than it used to be. Use as a trend, not gospel.
- Click Rate: Still the gold standard for engagement. If people aren’t clicking, your content or offer isn’t hitting.
- Unsubscribe Rate: If this jumps, you’re pushing too hard or your content isn’t relevant.
- Bounce Rate: High bounces mean you’ve got bad emails. Clean your list regularly.
- Spam Complaints: Even a handful is a red flag. Not just for reputation, but also for future deliverability.
Metrics to Not Obsess Over:
- Total Sends: Not helpful unless you’re troubleshooting.
- Forwards/Shares: Interesting, but rarely actionable.
- Device/Location Data: Fun for presentations, not for real decision-making.
Bottom line: Focus on what tells you if your message landed and got acted on.
3. Navigating Mailreef’s Campaign Analytics
Once you’ve sent a campaign, it’s time to dive into what Mailreef actually tells you.
Step-by-step:
- Go to the Campaigns tab.
-
Find your sent campaign and click into its detailed report.
-
Skim the summary, then dig deeper.
- The dashboard offers an overview: opens, clicks, unsubscribes, etc.
-
Don’t get hung up on percentages alone—look at raw numbers, especially if your list is small.
-
Click on “Engagement” or “Activity” details.
- See which links got clicked, and by whom (if you have subscriber-level tracking enabled).
-
Check how many people opened more than once, or forwarded the email. Repeat opens are usually a good sign.
-
Export data if you want to slice and dice.
- Mailreef lets you export CSVs for deeper analysis. Useful if you want to compare across campaigns or use your own tools.
A note on privacy: With recent privacy changes, especially on Apple devices, open rates are inflated. Don’t freak out if your numbers seem high or weird—focus on clicks and replies.
4. Comparing Campaigns Over Time
Looking at a single campaign tells you something. Looking at trends across several campaigns tells you what’s actually changing.
How to do it in Mailreef: - Use the “Compare Campaigns” feature (if available in your plan). Pick 3-5 recent campaigns with similar audiences. - Line up key metrics: open rate, click rate, unsubscribes. - Look for patterns, not one-off spikes. Did a new subject line boost opens, or did a new offer tank clicks?
What to watch for: - Consistent drop in opens/clicks: Maybe your list is getting stale or your content’s repetitive. - Sudden spike in unsubscribes: Did you change your tone, frequency, or offer something off-base? - High engagement on certain days/times: Use this to tweak your send schedule.
Don’t waste time: Comparing drastically different campaigns (like a holiday blast vs. a regular newsletter) isn’t helpful. Apples to apples, always.
5. Making Sense of Link Tracking and Click Maps
Clicks are where the action happens. Here’s how to make sense of Mailreef’s link tracking:
- Which links got the most clicks?
- If people only click the first link, maybe your email’s too long or the call-to-action is buried.
- Did anyone click the “unsubscribe” link by accident?
- Rare, but worth checking if you see weird spikes.
- Click maps: Visual overlays aren’t just pretty—they show you where people’s attention goes. If nobody’s scrolling, rethink your layout.
Pro tip: If you’re always seeing clicks on your logo and not your main CTA, it might be time to redesign your template or clarify your offer.
6. Segmenting Your Results for Real Insights
Broad averages hide the real story. Use Mailreef’s segmentation tools to break down your results:
- By audience segment: Are new subscribers engaging more than old ones? Are certain industries or regions clicking more?
- By activity: Who are your “super clickers”? Who never opens? Consider different follow-ups for each group.
- By device: If mobile users aren’t clicking, maybe your design isn’t mobile-friendly.
Ignore: Tiny differences between segments unless they’re dramatic. Small lists or small changes aren’t statistically meaningful.
7. What to Do With the Data
Data is useless unless you actually do something with it. Here’s how to put your findings to work:
- Test one thing at a time. Change subject lines, timing, or CTAs, but not all at once. Otherwise, you’ll never know what moved the needle.
- Re-engage the inactive. Set up an automated campaign for people who haven’t opened in 3+ months. If they still don’t bite, remove them.
- Reward your top engagers. Send early access or special offers to your most active subscribers.
- Stop sending to ghosts. Keeping unengaged emails on your list just hurts deliverability.
Don’t: Obsess over every tiny dip or jump. Look for trends, not outliers.
8. Common Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)
- Chasing perfect open rates. They’re never perfect—and aren’t as accurate as they used to be.
- Ignoring deliverability basics. Warm up new domains, clean lists, and authenticate. It’s boring, but it works.
- Overreacting to one bad campaign. Everyone sends a dud now and then. Focus on the long game.
- Not acting on unsubscribes. If lots of people leave, ask why. It’s usually fixable.
9. Reporting Results Without BS
If you’re sharing results with a team or boss, keep it simple:
- Highlight key wins: “Clicks rose 18% after we changed the subject line.”
- Flag red flags: “Unsubscribes doubled after the last send.”
- Suggest a next step: “Let’s test a shorter email next time.”
Skip the fluff. No one needs a 10-slide deck unless you’re paid by the slide.
Tracking and analyzing campaigns in Mailreef isn’t rocket science, but it does take some focus. Stick to the metrics that matter, ignore the noise, and don’t be afraid to experiment. The best marketers aren’t the ones with the fanciest dashboards—they’re the ones who keep it simple, pay attention, and keep tweaking.