If you’re running outbound email for B2B and your job (or bonus) depends on cold emails landing in the inbox, you know how fast things can go off the rails. Suddenly, your carefully crafted emails are hitting spam, responses dry up, and your boss is side-eyeing your numbers. There’s no shortage of tools promising to fix this—Mailreach, Instantly, Warmup Inbox, Lemwarm, and a dozen others. But which one actually helps you get more replies, and which ones are just adding noise?
This guide’s for people who don’t have time to waste and just want their emails delivered. We’ll break down what to actually look for when comparing Mailreach with other B2B go-to-market (GTM) tools, without the hype or vague promises.
1. Get Clear on What Matters (and What Doesn’t)
First, let’s cut through the nonsense. Cold email deliverability comes down to a few core things:
- Does your email get to the inbox, not spam or promotions?
- Does it look legit to recipients and to spam filters?
- Do you get actual replies and results, not just “opens”?
Most tools talk a big game about AI, smart scheduling, or “warming up” your inbox. Some of that helps, but a lot is window dressing. Focus on what actually moves the needle:
- Inbox placement (not just delivery)
- Domain reputation
- Consistent sending patterns
- Real human engagement
Ignore vanity metrics like “open rate” (Apple broke those anyway), or tools that just show pretty dashboards without fixing real problems.
2. Know What Mailreach and Its Competitors Actually Do
Before you compare, you need to know what these tools are and what they’re not. Here’s the honest breakdown:
What Mailreach (and Similar Tools) Do
- Inbox warmup: They send and receive emails between a network of accounts to make your sending look natural to spam filters.
- Monitor blacklist status: Let you know if your domain or IP lands on common blacklists.
- Deliverability reporting: Show if your emails are hitting inbox, spam, or promotions for different providers.
- Some have “auto-fix” features: Like rewriting subject lines or content to avoid spam triggers (hit and miss).
What They Don’t Do
- They don’t write your emails for you (at least not well enough to trust).
- They can’t fix a burned domain or bad data. If your domain’s already trashed, no tool is magic.
- They don’t replace a real sales engagement platform (like Outreach or Salesloft).
Pro tip: If a tool promises to “guarantee inboxing” or “triple your replies instantly,” run. No one can guarantee that.
3. Decide What You Need: Warmup, Monitoring, or Full Outbound?
Not every tool does the same thing, despite similar marketing. Figure out what you actually need:
- Just deliverability? (Inbox warmup, blacklist alerts, deliverability tests)
- Full cold email sending? (Sequencing, personalization, tracking, reply detection)
- A combo? (Some tools bundle deliverability with sequencing)
Mailreach focuses on deliverability and inbox warmup, not full campaign management. Tools like Instantly or Lemwarm offer warmup and campaign sending. Others like Warmup Inbox are basically just warmup.
Don’t pay for a Ferrari if you only need a bike. If you already have a sequencing tool, just get a dedicated warmup/monitoring tool. If you’re starting from scratch, a combo tool might make sense.
4. Run a Head-to-Head Test (What to Actually Compare)
Here’s how to honestly compare Mailreach with other B2B GTM tools:
a) Set Up a New Domain or Mailbox for Testing
Never test on your main domain. Grab a new one (or subdomain), set up proper DNS (SPF, DKIM, DMARC), and add it to each tool.
b) Use the Same Settings Across Tools
- Same sending volume
- Same email content (for test purposes)
- Same timing (days of week, hours)
This cuts out variables and lets you compare apples to apples.
c) Track These Real-World Metrics
- Inbox Rate
- Where do your emails land—primary inbox, promotions, spam?
-
Most tools claim to show this, but take it with a grain of salt. Run your own tests too (see below).
-
Blacklist and Reputation Alerts
- Does the tool actually catch issues before they become problems?
-
How often does it check, and how reliable are the alerts?
-
Warmup Quality
- Does the warmup network use real, aged inboxes or just throwaway accounts?
- Do they generate realistic replies, or is it obviously robotic?
-
How natural does the sending pattern look?
-
Support & Transparency
- How easy is it to get a straight answer from support?
-
Do they give you clear, honest advice, or just scripted responses?
-
Ease of Use
- Can you set it up in under 30 minutes?
- Is the reporting actually useful, or just noise?
Don’t get distracted by “AI-powered” features unless they directly improve one of the above. Most don’t.
d) Manual Tests You Should Run
- Seed Test: Send the same email to a list of your own test addresses on Gmail, Outlook, Yahoo, etc., and check where they land.
- Reply Test: See if replies from real people improve your inbox rate over time (they should).
- Blacklists: Use free tools like MXToolbox to double-check if you’re on any blacklists. Don’t trust just the vendor’s dashboard.
5. Price Isn’t Everything, But It Counts
Deliverability is important, but so is your budget. Here’s what you’ll find:
- Mailreach: Priced for just warmup/deliverability, usually $25–$50/month per inbox.
- Combo tools (Instantly, Lemwarm, etc.): More expensive, but you get sequencing and other features.
- Barebones tools: Sometimes dirt cheap, but often skimp on support or use low-quality warmup networks.
Look for flexible plans. You might only need warmup for a couple of new inboxes, not your whole team.
6. What Actually Works (And What’s Mostly Hype)
Works: - Warming up new inboxes before you start campaigns. - Monitoring blacklists and acting quickly if you get flagged. - Keeping sending patterns human—don’t blast 500 emails at 8am sharp. - Personalizing your emails (yes, real personalization).
Doesn’t Work: - Relying on open rates as a north star. - Believing any tool can “fix” a domain that’s already burned. - Using tools that fake engagement with obvious, generic replies—filters catch on fast.
Ignore: - AI subject line generators, unless you’re truly out of ideas. - Tools that promise “instant” results. Good deliverability takes weeks, not days.
7. Recommended Process for Staying Out of Spam
- Start every new domain with a warmup tool like Mailreach.
- Send real, personalized emails during warmup—not just tool-generated messages.
- Monitor your results weekly. If you see a dip, pause campaigns and investigate.
- Rotate inboxes and domains if you’re scaling. Don’t put all your eggs in one basket.
- Keep your lists clean. Bad data = bad reputation, no matter what tool you use.
Final Thoughts: Don’t Overcomplicate It
Deliverability tools are useful, but they’re not magic. The best stack is the one you’ll actually use and understand. Start simple. Test, measure, and be ready to change tools if you’re not getting results. Hype comes and goes, but landing in the inbox is a marathon, not a sprint.
If you’re overwhelmed, just pick a solid warmup tool, send human emails, and keep an eye on your results. You can always add bells and whistles later.