If you’re drowning in leads but only a handful ever buy, you’re not alone. Most sales and marketing teams waste hours sifting through junk, chasing the wrong people, or just guessing who’s worth a callback. Automating lead scoring and prioritization is your way out. This guide is for anyone who wants to stop spinning their wheels and actually close more deals—with less manual work.
We’ll walk through how to set up an automated lead scoring system using Icypeas, cut through the hype, and call out what’s actually useful (and what you can safely ignore). Let’s get to it.
Step 1: Get Clear on What Makes a Good Lead (and What Doesn’t)
Before you mess with any software, nail down what a “good” lead looks like for your business. This isn’t busywork—if you skip it, your automation will just be faster at sorting junk.
Ask yourself: - Who actually buys from you? (Industry, job title, budget, company size, etc.) - What signals show a lead is interested? (Opened emails, visited demo page, filled out a form) - What’s a red flag? (Competitors, students, tire-kickers)
Pro tip: Don’t overthink it. Start with what your gut says, then check your CRM for patterns among closed deals.
What to ignore: Fancy “lead fit” models that take weeks to build. You need something you can adjust on the fly.
Step 2: Map Out Your Lead Data Sources
You can’t score leads you can’t see. Make a quick list of everywhere your leads come from:
- Website forms
- Chatbots
- LinkedIn or other social media
- Webinars/events
- Purchased lists (not ideal, but let’s be real)
Why this matters: Icypeas isn’t magic—you’ll need some basic data (name, email, maybe company) for it to do its job. If your data is a mess, clean it up first.
Pro tip: If you have leads scattered across different tools, set up a simple integration to bring them into one place. Zapier, Make, or native integrations can work.
Step 3: Set Up Icypeas and Connect Your Lead Sources
Now, let’s get Icypeas plugged in and ready to roll.
-
Sign up for Icypeas
Head to Icypeas and register. (They offer a free trial, so you can poke around risk-free.) -
Connect your sources
- If you use a CRM like HubSpot, Salesforce, or Pipedrive, connect it directly.
- For website forms, use native integrations or something like Zapier.
-
Social leads? Export as CSV or set up an integration if possible.
-
Check your data flow
Import a few sample leads and make sure the info comes through cleanly—no weird formatting, missing fields, or duplicates.
What to ignore: Don’t waste hours wiring up edge-case data sources nobody uses. Focus on your main lead channels first.
Step 4: Build Your Lead Scoring Rules
Here’s where the magic (and a bit of common sense) happens.
The basics
Icypeas uses rules to assign scores to leads based on their attributes and behavior. For example: - +10 points if company has 100+ employees - +5 points if they opened your last email - -20 points if they’re from a blocked industry
How to set it up: 1. Go to the “Lead Scoring” or “Rules” section in Icypeas. 2. Add rules for each high-value attribute or behavior. Be specific. 3. Set negative scores for red flags—don’t be shy.
Example rules you might use
- Demographic:
- +10 if job title contains “Director” or “VP”
- +7 if company is in your target industry
- -10 if email is from a free provider (gmail.com, yahoo.com, etc.)
- Behavioral:
- +15 if they requested a demo
- +5 if they visited your pricing page twice
- -10 if they unsubscribed from emails
Pro tip: Keep it simple. You can always tweak or add more rules later. Don’t let “perfect” stop you from getting started.
Step 5: Set Up Lead Prioritization (So Reps Don’t Waste Time)
Lead scoring is only useful if it helps you act faster. Here’s how to set up prioritization in Icypeas:
- Create buckets or tiers (e.g., Hot, Warm, Cold) based on score ranges.
- Hot: 40+
- Warm: 20–39
- Cold: below 20
-
Automate assignments
Use Icypeas to route hot leads to your best reps or trigger instant notifications. -
Filter views
Set up dashboards or views so sales only sees leads worth calling. No more scrolling through endless lists.
What works:
- Letting reps focus on “Hot” leads and ignore the rest (at least initially).
- Reviewing “Warm” leads weekly to spot hidden gems.
What doesn’t:
- Trying to call every lead, every time. Let automation do the sorting.
Step 6: Automate Follow-Up Tasks (Without Annoying Your Leads)
Automation should help you move faster, not spam people into oblivion.
With Icypeas, you can: - Trigger follow-up emails when a lead hits “Hot” status. - Assign tasks or reminders to reps for high-priority leads. - Sync lead status back to your CRM, so everyone’s in the loop.
What to avoid:
- Don’t set up endless email drips for everyone. Segment by lead quality.
- Don’t hammer “Cold” leads. Focus on the ones with real potential.
Pro tip: Write a handful of quality follow-up emails—don’t rely on generic templates. Personalization wins.
Step 7: Measure, Adjust, and Don’t Get Lazy
Automated lead scoring isn’t “set it and forget it.” Stuff changes—your best lead source today could fizzle out next month.
- Check conversion rates by lead score bucket every month.
- Ask reps if the “Hot” leads are actually closing.
- Adjust your rules if you see weird patterns (e.g., low scores closing big deals).
What to ignore:
- Vanity metrics. If scoring makes you feel good but doesn’t boost conversions, it’s back to the drawing board.
Pro tip: Make small tweaks, not giant overhauls. Consistency beats complexity.
Final Thoughts: Keep It Simple, Iterate Often
Automating lead scoring and prioritization with Icypeas isn’t about building a perfect system overnight. Start with the basics, see what works, and change what doesn’t. The goal is to spend less time sorting leads and more time closing deals. Don’t let the promise of “AI-driven insights” distract you from the basics—good data, clear rules, and regular gut checks will get you further than hype ever will.
Stay skeptical, keep it simple, and don’t be afraid to adjust as you go. That’s how you actually improve conversion rates—one smart tweak at a time.