If you’re running B2B email campaigns and want to get more replies—not just opens—you already know you need to test what you send. But most folks either overcomplicate A/B testing or run sloppy tests that don’t teach them a thing. This guide is for people who use Inboxautomate and want to run smarter, more useful A/B tests on their subject lines and messaging. If you want less guesswork and more real results, read on.
Why Bother A/B Testing at All? (And Why Most Tests Suck)
A/B testing in B2B email is about getting measurable improvements, not chasing “best practices” you read on LinkedIn. The problem? Most people try to test everything at once, run too-small tests, or change so many things they have no idea what actually worked.
Here’s what you’re actually after: - Higher open rates (so your emails don’t just sit in the void) - More replies or clicks (aka actual business outcomes) - Real learnings, not just random spikes
If you’re not getting these, you’re probably wasting time.
Step 1: Decide What’s Worth Testing
Before you build out any tests in Inboxautomate, get clear on what you’re trying to improve. Not everything is worth testing—focus on what drives outcomes.
What to test: - Subject lines: Drives open rates. Worth testing, but don’t get obsessed—sometimes tweaks barely move the needle. - Message body: The actual pitch, value prop, or call to action. This is where most B2B campaigns win or lose. - Sender name/address: Occasionally worth testing, especially if you’re seeing deliverability issues. - Timing/day of week: Usually overrated, but if you’re sending big volumes, small gains add up.
What NOT to test: - Emojis in B2B subject lines. Most buyers aren’t impressed. - Wildly different offers at once. You’ll never know what worked. - Too many variables at once. Classic rookie move.
Pro tip: Start with the subject line and the first sentence of your message. If those don’t hook people, nothing else matters.
Step 2: Set Up Clean, Controlled A/B Tests in Inboxautomate
If you’re new to Inboxautomate, the A/B testing interface is straightforward. But don’t just use the defaults and hope for the best.
How to do it right:
-
Pick one variable to test per campaign.
For example, test two subject lines, not two subject lines plus two message bodies. Keep it simple. -
Make your test groups large enough.
Don’t test on 20 emails and call it a day. For B2B, try for at least 100+ contacts per variation if you can. Smaller lists mean more noise and less signal. -
Randomize your split.
Inboxautomate will do this for you, but double-check you haven’t uploaded a list where all your “A”s are from one industry and all your “B”s are from another. -
Set a clear success metric.
- Subject line tests: Open rate is your metric.
-
Messaging tests: Reply rate or click rate (if you use links—though for B2B, replies often matter more).
-
Run the test long enough.
Don’t pull the plug after a handful of responses. Wait at least 48-72 hours, or until you see a clear pattern—whichever comes later.
Pitfall to avoid:
Don’t “peek” at your results every hour and call a winner early. That’s not a real test—that’s wishful thinking.
Step 3: Craft Variations That Actually Teach You Something
It’s tempting to make tiny tweaks (“What if I add ‘Re:’ to the subject line?”) or huge overhauls (“Let’s try a totally different message!”). Both can be a waste.
How to create useful tests:
- Make meaningful changes:
Don’t just swap a single word. Try different angles, tones, or value props. Example: - Subject line A: “Quick question about your hiring process”
-
Subject line B: “Cut your time-to-hire by 30%—how?”
-
Keep the rest constant:
The only way you’ll know what worked is if everything else stays the same. -
Don’t chase cleverness:
If you wouldn’t open your own email, why would anyone else? Avoid “clickbait”—it may boost opens but kill replies.
Pro tip:
Write all your variations before loading them into Inboxautomate. Don’t “improvise” in the tool. You’ll avoid silly mistakes and keep your tests honest.
Step 4: Measure Results Honestly (Ignore the Vanity Metrics)
Once the campaign runs, Inboxautomate gives you clear stats: open rates, reply rates, clicks, bounces, and more. But don’t just chase the highest numbers—make sure you’re measuring what matters.
How to actually interpret results:
- Subject line tests:
- Higher open rate is good, but… check that it doesn’t tank reply rate. Sometimes a “curiosity” subject line gets opens but fewer replies.
- Message body tests:
-
Focus on replies or qualified meetings booked—not just clicks.
-
Ignore:
- Unsubscribes (unless they spike)
- “Positive sentiment” from AI tools (these are guesses, not gospel)
Statistical significance:
Look, unless you’re sending thousands of emails, don’t get bogged down in fancy math. If you see a 5% difference after 500 sends, it’s probably real. If it’s 2% after 30 sends, it’s noise.
What if it’s a tie?
That’s fine. Not every test will be a breakthrough. Move on and test something else.
Step 5: Use What You Learn—But Don’t Fall for “Winner’s Curse”
Let’s say your “B” subject line crushed “A.” Great. Use it as your new control, but don’t assume it will work forever. B2B audiences get fatigued, and what works this month may flop next quarter.
What to do next: - Roll out winners to future campaigns, but keep testing new ideas. - Save your “winning” subject lines and messages, but don’t recycle them endlessly. - Document what DIDN’T work—sometimes that’s even more valuable.
A word on over-optimization:
Don’t waste weeks squeezing out another 1-2% if you haven’t fixed bigger issues (like targeting the wrong people, or your offer not fitting the audience).
Step 6: Keep It Legal and Respectful
Not the most exciting part, but important. When you’re testing, don’t forget:
- Avoid misleading subject lines (that’s how you end up in spam or flagged for phishing).
- Respect opt-outs and privacy laws (GDPR, CAN-SPAM, etc.).
- Don’t bombard the same leads with every test. Rotate your lists.
What Actually Works? (And What’s Mostly Hype)
Works: - Plain, clear subject lines that make a real promise. - Personal, short opening lines in the body. - Testing one thing at a time. - Using reply rate as your main metric.
Mostly hype: - Fancy formatting or graphics in B2B cold emails. - “Power words” or copywriting tricks—B2B buyers see through it. - Sending at exactly 10:07 AM for “peak open rates.” You’re overthinking it.
Wrapping Up: Don’t Overthink It
A/B testing in Inboxautomate isn’t magic. It’s a way to learn what actually works with your real audience—not what a blog post told you. Start simple, test one thing at a time, and pay attention to replies, not just opens.
When in doubt, ask yourself: “Would I respond to this email?” If not, neither will your prospects. Keep it simple, keep testing, and don’t be afraid to ditch what doesn’t work. The best campaigns are the most honest ones.